The ongoing effort to deliver humanitarian aid directly to Gaza has led to the detention of at least five Irish citizens after a fleet of vessels organized by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) was intercepted by Israeli forces in international waters on Wednesday.
The detainees are believed to include Independent TD Barry Heneghan and author Naoise Dolan. This is the second such high-profile interception in the region within a week, following the detention of over 450 activists aboard the larger Global Sumud Flotilla.
Conflicting Claims on Legality and Intent
The Freedom Flotilla Coalition, an international network of pro-Palestinian activist groups, accused Israeli forces of illegally “hijack[ing] the humanitarian fleet.” The FFC emphasized that the ships carried over $110,000 in vital medical and nutritional supplies intended for Gaza’s hospitals, arguing that their non-violent mission does not pose a threat and operates outside of Israeli jurisdiction.
“The Israeli military has no legal jurisdiction over international waters,” the FFC stated, demanding the immediate release of the participants—who include doctors, journalists, and humanitarians from across the world—whom they say were “taken against their will.”
Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, however, defended its actions. In a statement on X, the ministry claimed the interception successfully thwarted “another futile attempt to breach the legal naval blockade and enter a combat zone.” It confirmed that all passengers were safe, transferred to an Israeli port, and were expected to be deported promptly.
The Broader Context of Blockade
The interception takes place amidst a severe humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Authorities there report that approximately 67,000 people have been killed since the October 7, 2023, attack by Hamas, which Israel says killed 1,200 people.
The legality of Israel’s blockade, particularly its enforcement in international waters, remains a point of major contention under international law. Humanitarian and human rights groups, as well as several international legal experts, have repeatedly condemned the naval blockade, calling it a contravention of international human rights and humanitarian law. Proponents of the blockade, including the Israeli government, maintain it is militarily justified to prevent weapons smuggling into the territory.
