Public patients aged 60 and over will no longer be able to access MRI scans for hip and knee problems through their GP, under a cost-saving measure by the Health Service Executive (HSE).
An internal HSE report seen by RTÉ News shows that hip and knee MRI scans are being removed from the GP Access to Community Diagnostics Scheme for this age group. The change means GPs can no longer refer older patients for the scan under the scheme.
The review was carried out by the HSE Cost and Productivity Oversight Group. It estimates that around 21,600 MRI scans of this type are normally carried out in a full year, although another report puts the figure at about 21,000. An internal HSE financial report dated October 30 said officials were still working to estimate the savings the change would generate.
The HSE relies largely on private providers to deliver these diagnostics, and the report found that it was already €8.1 million over budget on medical imaging by the end of September. Labour’s health spokesperson Marie Sherlock said spending on third-party imaging was 21% over budget by the same date.
In a statement, the HSE confirmed the change. “To align clinical practice with evidence-based guidance and to support the appropriate use of radiology resources, MRI of the hip and knee is being removed from the scope of the GP Access to Community Diagnostics Scheme for patients aged 60 years and over, following a review of referral activity, clinical evidence and international best-practice guidelines,” it said.
It added that MRI “is not routinely indicated in the assessment of osteoarthritis of the hip and knee in older adults.” The HSE said that for most patients in this age group, diagnosis can be made through clinical assessment and, where needed, a plain X-ray. It stressed that the change “does not prevent patients from accessing MRI where clinically indicated,” and that it was based on clinical evidence rather than on capacity. It also acknowledged that “the efficient use of finite MRI capacity is an important consideration,” and said the move follows an audit earlier this year.
The GP Access to Community Diagnostics Scheme, introduced in January 2021, is a central part of the Enhanced Community Care programme. It lets GPs directly refer patients aged 16 and over for X-ray, CT, MRI and DXA scans at private providers, paid for by the HSE, which is intended to ease pressure on hospitals. The scheme delivers around 240,000 scans each year. According to the Department of Health, more than 280,000 scans were completed through it in 2024, reducing the number of patients needing diagnostic referral to emergency departments by more than 85%.
Ms Sherlock described the decision as “regressive” and said it “creates a significant inequality issue for older people.” She said it was “a really blunt cut” that would hurt people without health insurance who cannot get quick access to a diagnostic image, and who would face waiting lists of 18 months or more to see a consultant. She argued that the main reason for the cut was that the HSE depends heavily on private imaging providers and is now having to apply cutbacks. She said access to MRI is particularly important for knee conditions.
One representative responding to the announcement said the HSE should prepare communication material for patients, rather than leaving the onus on GPs to explain the change.
The move comes as the HSE tries to contain budget overruns. On Tuesday, Cabinet ministers approved a €780 million supplementary budget for the Executive, on top of the €29 billion allocated for 2026. HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor said on Wednesday that she has made progress in reducing overspending since taking up the role earlier this year.
The HSE has not said when the change will take effect.