National News

COP31 Collapses Without Deal as EU, Led by Ireland’s O’Brien, Rejects Pact That Omits Fossil Fuels

“Unconscionable” to Have a Climate Pact Without Fossil Fuels, Says Irish Minister Darragh O'Brien as COP31 Breaks Down
“Unconscionable” to Have a Climate Pact Without Fossil Fuels, Says Irish Minister Darragh O'Brien as COP31 Breaks Down

The COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, has ended without an agreement after the European Union and a number of other countries refused to endorse a final pact that made no mention of fossil fuels.

Ireland’s Minister for Climate, Darragh O’Brien, speaking on behalf of the EU, said the bloc would not accept the text. Ireland currently holds the rotating EU presidency.

“We will not endorse a cover decision or an Antalya pact that does not even mention fossil fuels, which is the key driver of climate change,” Mr O’Brien told delegates. He said the proposal amounted to “greenwashing” fossil fuels and was “negotiating backwards in time.” Speaking to AFP outside the plenary hall, he said the summit had been “hijacked by some oil states.”

COP31 President Murat Kurum conceded that consensus had not been reached. “I understand that there is no agreement on this text. For that reason, these decisions have not been adopted,” he told the closing session. He later said there would be no new draft.

The collapse followed a sharp change of fortune. In the early hours of Sunday, Mr Kurum told a late-night plenary that a new package contained a text “which all the parties can agree upon.” He said concerns about fossil fuels and about helping developing countries pay for adaptation had been addressed. Delegations were given until 3am Irish time to raise objections, with a session at 6am to approve the deal. Instead, the EU, Panama, Vanuatu and Belize rejected it. The Marshall Islands also spoke strongly against it.

The talks had already run well past a Friday deadline, and ended 44 hours after the summit’s scheduled close, making COP31 the longest UN climate conference ever held. On Saturday, threats of a walkout led Turkey and Australia, which is leading the negotiations, to convene an urgent meeting between the EU and Saudi Arabia, but no compromise was found.

Decisions at UN climate talks must be made by consensus, so a single country among the nearly 200 involved can block an agreement. Oil-producing states led by Saudi Arabia lobbied for any mention of fossil fuels to be removed. The final draft included only an oblique reference to a 2023 global agreement to shift away from fossil fuels, without naming them. It also kept a push to expand carbon capture, a technology backed by the fossil fuel industry but criticised as costly and ineffective.

Saudi negotiator Mohammad Ayoub, speaking for the Arab Group, said “all solutions” should be on the table and that countries should select from them according to national circumstances. A Russian representative said it could not agree to any formulation on fossil fuels.

The draft also proposed raising the share of electricity in total final energy consumption to 35% by 2035, but did not require that electricity to come from renewable sources. Around a third of global electricity is produced from coal and about a fifth from gas. It expressed “deep concern” that global warming will exceed 1.5C, the limit countries agreed in Paris more than a decade ago.

Other issues also divided delegates. Saudi Arabia, India and Kenya tried to delay the next major reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, while dozens of countries wanted them published in time for a 2028 global stocktake. Developing countries were angered by the removal of a $120 billion target for climate adaptation finance. “We need finance, yet our partners showed up to this COP with empty hands,” said Marshall Islands climate envoy Kathy Jetnil-Kijiner.

UK negotiator Kate Hughes said she was “profoundly disappointed,” calling the text a “lowest common denominator.” Sara Shaw of 350.org said: “This text isn’t a climate plan. It’s a licence to keep polluting.”

The summit took place against a backdrop of high energy prices and tensions linked to the war between the United States and Iran, and followed confirmation by the UN’s environment body that global temperatures are set to exceed 1.5C.

More stories

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Free news alerts

Never miss an Irish news update

Join the EireNow WhatsApp group and get breaking news sent straight to your phone.

Join on WhatsApp